Cornell Analysis Finds Confusion in Recent Supreme Court Employment Decisions
November 6, 2015 8:49am
Ithaca, NY, November 6, 2015 – Two recent holdings by the U.S. Supreme Court have been hailed as "victories" for employees seeking personal accommodations under civil rights law. However, a new analysis from the Cornell Institute for Hospitality Labor and Employment Relations (CIHLER) finds little real change—along with considerable confusion—regarding the Court's actual holding. The analysis, "The United States Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Employees in the Young and Abercrombie Cases: What Do They Really Hold?," is written by David Sherwyn and David B. Ritter. Sherwyn is the John and Melissa Ceriale Professor of Hospitality Human Resources, professor of law at Cornell University's School of Hotel Administration, and CIHLER director. Ritter is a partner in the Chicago office of Barnes & Thornburg. Published in association with the Center for Hospitality Research, Sherwyn and Ritter's analysis is available at no charge.
"What we see here is that although the Court did disturb a long-standing precedent in one case, there is no real expansion in the scope of accommodations required for pregnant employees or for employees' religious observances," Sherwyn noted. "That said, the Court was crystal clear that employers cannot discriminate in hiring based on the expectation that an employee might request a religious accommodation."
The decisions in question are Young v. United Parcel Service, Inc., and E.E.O.C. v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc. In the Young case, the Court disturbed precedent by essentially requiring that the facts of each pregnancy accommodation situation must be tried under a challenging new standard. In the Abercrombie case, the Court did not change the precedent regarding the extent to which an employer should go to accommodate a religious belief, but affirmed the civil rights principle that an employer cannot discriminate in a hiring decision based on suppositions regarding a prospective employee's religious observances. However, Ritter and Sherwyn note an interesting question yet to be resolved in cases of religious accommodation, namely, whether the burden of proof rests on the employer or employee. This is an important point, since the party bearing the burden of proof may find it difficult to win its case.
cornell school of hotel administration,
center for hospitality research,
cornell institute for hospitality labor and employment relations,
The Cornell Institute for Hospitality Labor and Employment Relations was established in 2013 as a platform for students, employers, employees, unions, and their advocates involved in the hospitality industry. The institute's mission is to support educational programs, sponsor and disseminate research, and hold conferences and roundtables dedicated to modernizing labor and employment relations, analyzing labor and employment law, and improving human resource management and leadership in the hospitality industry. To achieve this goal, the institute supports classes focusing on labor and employment relations; disseminates empirical, theoretical, and doctrinal scholarship; and sponsors conferences and roundtables.
Contact: Erica Heim
The 93rd Annual Hotel Ezra Cornell Conference Theme "A Sense of Place" to Explore the Experience Era in the Hospitality Industry
IDeaS Announces 2017 Cornell Revenue Management Scholarship Recipients
Cornell Presents the 2017 Center for Hospitality Research Sustainability Roundtable Summary
The 2017 Cornell/ICHRIE Howard B. Meek Award Presented to Dr. Fred DeMicco
Top 5 Takeaways from Cornell's Master of Management in Hospitality Leadership Development Program
Cornell CHR Report Asks: "Do Property Characteristics or Cash Flow Drive Hotel Real Estate Value? The Answer Is Yes”
Cornell Research on Hotel Brand Standards: How to Pick the Right Amenities for Your Property
Cornell Study on Labor Law: When Rules Are Made to Be Broken: The Case of Sexual Harassment Law
Cornell Study Examines Emerging Trends in Hotel Revenue Management
Cheryl Boyer to Serve as 2017 Cornell Hotel Society President
Cornell Study Highlights Diversification Benefits of REIT Stock Investments
Cornell Study Examines How Bias Affects Hiring Practices
Hotel Investment Climate Remains Favorable Despite Interest Rate Increases, Cornell Study Suggests
Roundtable Focuses on High-Tech Adoption in Hospitality Industry
Aimed to Help Hotels Reduce Restaurant Food Waste, Cornell Offers New Tool, FRESH: A Food-service Sustainability Rating
Hospitality Money Managers Should Avoid Short-term Trading According to New Cornell Study
Cornell Tool Allows Restaurants to Evaluate Early Bird & Night Owl Menu Specials Effectiveness
Cornell Study Puts Retaliation Claims in a Class by Themselves
Likely Boost for Hotel Profits According to Cornell Analysis
Please login or register to post a comment.